A script by Jellifish (Jake)
“I see a Demon in your future. And in hers. And in his, and his, and — oh. Oh dear. Has anyone else looked into the ball tonight?”
The good team has a dozen Fortune Tellers to choose from, and the evil team has spent years learning how to make that a curse. Every Fortune Teller has their own red herring, so two honest seers can look at the same player and come back with different answers.
Twelve copies of one ability sounds like the town gets an easy win. It doesn't. A Poisoner, a Pit-Hag, a Goon and a Cerenovus all get stronger when the town is full of Fortune Tellers. Legion can make nearly every reading a “yes”. And a Recluse can poison any reading that lands on them. The puzzle isn't whether to trust a Fortune Teller. It's which one and which night.
Each night, choose 2 players: you learn if either is a Demon. There is a good player that registers as a Demon to you.
Why a Bootlegger rule and not the Pope? Normally a character can only be in play once. The Pope would allow duplicate copies of the same character. Here, each Fortune Teller is a unique numbered character, so there is never a duplicate. That keeps every number a real, individual claim. Demon bluffs can name a specific number, the Pit-Hag can create one, and the Cerenovus can make someone mad about being one.
Each unused Fortune Teller number is a not-in-play character. It can be given to the Demon as a bluff, so “I'm Fortune Teller 9” can be a safe evil claim when 9 isn't in play.
You do not know what your ability is. Each day, privately guess what it is: you learn how accurate you are.
With twelve Fortune Tellers on the script, “I'm a Fortune Teller” is the obvious first guess. An Amnesiac ability that looks like a Fortune Teller's, but with a twist, is very much in theme.
Each night, the 1st player to choose you with their ability is drunk until dusk. You become their alignment.
With up to twelve Fortune Tellers waking in order, someone will pick the Goon. The first one to do so gets a drunk reading. Minions that wake earlier can hit the Goon first and pull them evil.
You might register as evil & as a Minion or Demon, even if dead.
The Recluse is a built-in red herring for every Fortune Teller. You can have them register as a Demon to some Fortune Tellers and not others.
If you are “mad” about being an Outsider, you might be executed.
The Mutant's easiest hiding place is claiming one of twelve Fortune Teller numbers, and it's the first thing an evil player will try too.
When you learn that you died, publicly choose 1 alive player. Tonight, if it was a good player, they die.
The town's pile of Fortune Teller readings is the Moonchild's best guide to who is safe to pick.
Each night, choose a player & a good character: they are “mad” they are this character tomorrow, or might be executed.
“Be mad you're Fortune Teller 7” puts a fake seer, with fake readings, into a town that is already full of seers.
Each night, choose a player: they are poisoned tonight and tomorrow day.
Each night the Poisoner picks which seer's reading goes wrong.
Each night*, choose a player & a character they become (if not-in-play). If a Demon is made, deaths tonight are arbitrary.
Every unused Fortune Teller number is a not-in-play character the Pit-Hag can hand out. When someone becomes a new Fortune Teller, give them a red herring as they arrive.
There are extra Outsiders in play. [+2 Outsiders]
Two more Outsiders means fewer real Fortune Tellers and more Goon, Recluse and Mutant noise.
Each night*, choose a player: they die. If you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
The Demon every Fortune Teller is looking for. Starpassing makes yesterday's clean readings go stale.
Each night*, a player might die. Executions fail if only evil voted. You register as a Minion too. [Most players are Legion]
Most of the table is a Demon, so most readings come back “yes”. In a Legion game, a “no” is the valuable answer.
Compare readings across Fortune Tellers. A player who pings for one seer but not another is probably that seer's red herring. A player who pings for everyone is worth worrying about.
Claim a Fortune Teller number nobody has taken, and back it up with readings. You can blame any “wrong” answer on your red herring.
Keep the RH tokens straight. A grimoire with five Fortune Tellers and five red herrings fills up fast, so put each herring token next to its Fortune Teller's number.